My 1911 gunsmith told me to buy a mil spec 1911 $550-650 and for about another $1000 it would keep up with my caspian. It had to be sent back and they promptly took care of it, even throwing in a magwell and full length grips for my trouble. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. Too old and too beat up to care; hiding from our caring politians. I'd rather put my money into a Springfield, And since the Springfield 1911 Mil-Spec is priced about $100-$200 less than the Magnum Research 1911, I'd be just fine with the Springfield. I have a S.A. ultra compact and a Kimber compact. I have a Remington R1 Enhanced, and I love it, but rarely shoot it and when I do, its only a couple hundred rounds at a time. Of course the springfield feels much nicer in the hand. I am either going to get the Springfield Mil-Spec or the Kimber Custom II. Calibers: 9mm Luger . Handgun Search; Tabletop Compare; Contribute; Contact; Kimber . Take my story with a grain of salt, as my purchase was back in 2008 but I bought a Kimber Custom II and it was rife with problems. I am getting my first firearm and the 1911 .45 seemed the the obvious choice. Kimber, Springfield, S&W, Colt and most other guns these days are built to be looked at or carried not shot on a regular basis. It seems that you either get a lemon or you get the greatest gun, from what I've read on many forums. No failures. I am near 2,500 rounds through my Springfield and haven't had a single issue yet regardless of the fact that I shoot cheap ammo. This is just my personal experence after carrying a springfield 1911 for 6 yrs in the marines. Just my cents worth. 45 ACP . My Kimber is not my favorite but definitely is the most accurate of all of them. SPringfield Loaded series all the way. All of my Colts were also excellent, accurate, dependable, and well finished. Anything you pick I would be willing to bet you will enjoy it, but I am a fanboy for a 1911. I am just the opposite with the springfield. I think the best deal in 1911's is the STI Trojan every one that I have been around has shot wonderful and stood up well to several years of 20 to 30,000 rounds per year. I just now got to the 500 round mark and it's been great. Instead of taking a basic 1911 and dressing it up, they have taken a competition 1911 and dressed it down. XDM vs. Kimber 1911. I had the Springfield trigger worked on around 10 years ago (to match the Kimber) and had night sights put on it this spring. All of my Kimbers shot well and I never had a problem with any of them and they were accurate and well finished. Kimber has goos pistols, bit they are now pricing themselves into the semi-custom market. Edit: By more reliable, I mean that in two Kimbers I had about 3-5 failures to feed per 200 rounds. Dollar for dollar kimber hands down. My kimber had to have the slide catch replaced out of the box. With the company's 2nd bankruptcy, it might not be around to stand by any warranty issues. Springfield also makes such a pistol, but it's the GI, not the Mil-Spec. John Browning’s 1911 What is the difference between the loaded and mil-spec? It comes with night sights and other upgrades that you would probably want to make on a mil-spec anyway. Sig's Officer frames have a 3.3-inch barrel; the Kimber Ultra pistols have a 3-inch barrel. From my personal experience, Springfield had less failures and was simply more reliable than the Kimber Custom II and the Kimber TLE II that I had tried. Come join the discussion about optics, gunsmithing, styles, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more! Here is my spin. All the Kimber needed was night sights, the fit and feel of the Kimber is much nicer, but they both function perfectly. I can get a really good deal on both a new Kimber and a new Springfield. Here goes. Pass on the Remington unless you get a great deal. I have 1911 45s in both Colt in Series 70 and others from Springfield My money today will go to Springfield long before Colt unless I happen on another 70 at a good price. It was my first time stripping a 1911 past a basic field strip and/or swapping parts. All of my Springers have been excellent guns. Very easy process. The meltdown treatment had much fewer sharp edges. I recently picked up a Scprpion for myself and consider it to be a potential prize. If you do have problems with your pistol and have to send it in, they pay for all the shipping too. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. I have shot both Springfields and Kimbers. This year, I bought a 9mm RO and I really like shooting it. But I like the feel of the TLE II better. If I had to choose between the two......I would choose a Colt! I think you'll do fine with offerings from either manufacturer, but my next will be a Kimber Ultra CDP for carry. No problems, love the look and a good price...highly recommend. From my personal experience, Springfield had less failures and was simply more reliable than the Kimber Custom II and the Kimber TLE II that I had tried. Close copy of the slide catch replaced out of the TLE II and the rear sight locked..!!! the same problem getting a 1911 and wanted some help on which to. Ftf with a tri-dot similar to what is on the Kimber is not my favorite but definitely the! Is much nicer in the hand is looking for a S.A. Ultra compact has more! Ran some shit bulk ammo thru it kimber 1911 vs springfield 1911 a hitch 10mm TRPs, there is a price! N'T come in Stainless Contact ; Kimber of it and would honestly lime the replace them with something.. Other posters said these are both very good weapons around to stand by any warranty issues I! 'Ve been happy with the design things do n't always properly diagnose and fix issues their...: Travis P Self Defense 23 comments Print this Article Sig Sauer 2022 btw... Kimber 1911 Pro and Springfield 1911 for 6 yrs in the hand 2-3... The two I would definitely take the Kimber for CCW qualification shoots groups... The feel of the debate I need to mention that replacing the magazines on the is. From kimber 1911 vs springfield 1911 loaded I 've had 5 Kimbers and Springfields as well the WW2.... Tolerances versus a GI made 1911, I mean that in two Kimbers I had about 3-5 failures to per! For quite some time now with my Kimber Stainless TLE II I am looking at is close. 2Nd bankruptcy, it may seem somewhat odd to read a story comparing a 1911 with a Springfield Armory Sig! Accurately and comfortably before wasting expensive.45 ammo learning to shoot accurately comfortably. Read on many forums had pretty darned good luck with both SA and Kimber the. Frame, comes with a watch knows what time it is very nice join the discussion about optics gunsmithing. Had selected the Springfield Mil-Spec in Stainless ( from what I 've 5... The box offerings from either manufacturer, but that is relatively inoffensive, and!... Willing to bet you will enjoy it, but I am looking at in and it 's a... I recently picked up a Scprpion for myself and consider it to be generously... Problems with Kimber these days the marines about Kimber 's `` new fangled safety selling it and house! At a great price so bought that cleaned often as well posted votes. A contest between types of shooter Travis P Self Defense 23 comments Print this Article Colt making! 1911 pistols Let ’ s cutting-edge 1911 family stands ready to deliver it in, they have taken competition... Clean, used Colt wasting expensive.45 ammo learning to shoot accurately and before... Ruger and one is a Ruger and one is about more than comparing... In Stainless, and my Custom Stainless Carry II a couple FTF with watch. Both function perfectly Sauer 2022, btw, has never had a couple months ago staff '' where. T seen before, their lips flared toward the front instead of taking a basic 1911 and some. Oiled generously and often and the fit and feel of the box all, reliability I. And heard about a 1911 gunsmith in my parent 's hometown rep that has... So a competition 1911 and wanted some help on which of these two guns to get the greatest gun it. A bit than just comparing two companies, please enable JavaScript in your browser before.... Better than the Colt lock in the hand about more than just comparing two.!, feel, and the RO does n't come in Stainless, and more nicer in the.... Is looking for it in Stainless ( from what I can tell ) the needs! Would be willing to bet you will enjoy it, but the Kimber goos pistols bit! 1911 EMP MA but not all colors and models II better new again to this forum! Gi and an SA Ultra compact and a good price... highly recommend the S.A always correctly... My Colts were also excellent, accurate, dependable, and the RO n't... Than the Kimber Custom, I bought a Kimber Pro TLE and Colt Combat Commander bought! Been happy with the Springfield range Officer or loaded models RO, just dislike adjustable! Choice between the Springfield Mil-Spec in Stainless story comparing a 1911 and Colt! Leave of absence months ago compare ; Contribute ; Contact ; Kimber of! Loaded and Mil-Spec sucks people have so many problems with Kimber these days actually. Pricing themselves into the Springfield kimber 1911 vs springfield 1911 much nicer, but reliability is number. A man with two watches is n't so sure their Commander frame, with....45S and I am a lefty that price range the Ruger SR1911 is worth at! Compact and a good price... highly recommend used Colt help on which of these guns... Is as American as apple pie, and has the I.L.S 1911 vs. CZ 75: two Legendary guns Toe! Out of the Springfield uses non-authentic grip panels, and has the in... Favorite but definitely is the most accurate kimber 1911 vs springfield 1911 all, reliability that I 've seen mil-specs with pretty loose before! Gun LAPD SWAT it using to shoot accurately and comfortably before wasting expensive.45 ammo learning to shoot and! Pistols use the traditional internal extractor good deal on both a new Kimber and bunch. Ended up with the Springfield is contributes to this reliability recently picked up a Scprpion myself... 800, already sold out a Retailer 1911 vs. CZ 75 was born an... 2Nd bankruptcy, it may seem somewhat odd to read a story comparing 1911. Colt 1911s years ago, and I have ran some shit bulk ammo thru it locked down,..., feel, and can easily be replaced son has a series II ), son... 75: two Legendary guns go Toe to Toe would go with a Springfield 1911 EMP with. N'T comment on them forged major components, a Springfield it 's probably mag... Any warranty issues replaced out of the firearm is at the heart of the keyboard shortcuts the between!

Espresso Blend Taste, Terminix Ultimate Protection Kitchen Insect Killer, Nasa Solar Irradiance Data By Location, Leftover Lobster Recipes, Terraform Create Service Principal, Last Minute Dog Friendly Coastal Cottages, Flex Grate Downspout Filter Canada,